I was there when
the carabinieri raided the IndyMedia Center and the Diaz school, in Genoa, at
the end of the protest against the G8 meeting. We heard the shouts and
screams, couldn’t get out the door, ran upstairs and hid, fearing for our
lives. Eventually the cops found us, but we were the lucky ones. A Member of
Parliament was in our building; lawyers and media arrived. There was some
obscure Italian legal reason why the police could be deterred. They withdrew.
could save our friends across the street at the school where people were
sleeping and where another section of Independent Media was located. The
police entered, the media and the politicians were kept out, and they beat
people. They beat people who had been sleeping, who held up their hands in a
gesture of innocence and cried out, “pacifisti, pacifisti.” They broke bones,
smashed teeth, shattered skulls. They left blood on the walls, on the windows,
a pool of it in every spot where people had been sleeping. When they finished
their work, they brought in the ambulances. We watched as the stretchers were
carried out, as people were taken to the jail ward of the hospital or to jail.
In the jail, many of them were tortured again, in rooms with pictures of
Mussolini on the wall.
happened. Not in the 1930s, but on the night of July 21 and the morning of
July 22, 2001. Not in a third world country, but in Italy: prosperous,
civilized, sunny Italy. As terrifying as that night was, what is more
frightening are its implications:
- That the police could carry
out such a brutal act openly, in the face of lawyers, politicians, and the
media means that they do not expect to be held accountable for their actions.
Which means that they had support from higher up, from more powerful
politicians. According to a report published in La Repubblica from a
cop who took part in the raid, when the more democratic factions within the
police complained that the Constitution was being violated, they were told,
“We don’t have anything to be worried about, we’re covered.”
- That those politicians also
do not expect to be condemned or driven from office means that they too have
support from higher up, ultimately, from Berlusconi, Italy’s Prime Minister.
- That they could beat,
torture, and falsely arrest Italians means that they do not expect to be held
accountable by their own people.
- That they could beat,
torture, and imprison internationals shows that they do not expect to be held
accountable by the international community.
- That Berlusconi could
support such acts means that he must be certain of support from other
international powers and that these overtly fascist actions are linked to the
growing international escalation of repression against protestors.
- That the Italian government
used tactics learned from Quebec: the wall, the massive use of tear gas, and
that the RCMP had observers in Genoa in preparation for next year’s meeting in
Calgary, means that police repression is also a global network. As we learn
from each action, so do they.
- That the Italian government
is now targeting the organizers of the Genoa Social Forum shows where their
agenda was heading all along: the discrediting of the antiglobalization
network and the discouraging of peaceful and legal protest as well as direct
action. The leader of the Forum has lost his job. Others are fearing for their
freedom and safety.
It’s hard to
make sense of all that happened in Genoa. The Black Bloc suddenly appeared in
the midst of a square that was supposed to be a safe space for peaceful
gatherings: the police gas and beat the pacifists and let the Bloc escape. We
were having a quiet lunch in the convergence center by the sea, when suddenly
tear gas cannisters were flying into the eating area and a pitched battle
began directly outside, just 100 yards away from the main march. Prisoners
report being tortured until they agreed to shout “Viva Il Duce!” The police
rationale for the attack on the school was the supposed presence of members of
the Black Bloc—but they never attacked the actual Black Bloc encampment. By
the night of the attack most of the Black Bloc had left the city.
I’m not an
investigative reporter, I’m an activist and once upon a time was a novelist. I
don’t like conspiracy theories but I make sense of the world through stories.
Genoa makes sense to me if this is the plot:
Italian Security to Italian Government/U.S. and International Advisors:
Subject: Covert Security Plan for Genova.
Lead up to the action: This phase is characterized by two major aspects: the
creation of a climate of fear and anticipated violence by the stockpiling of
body bags, deployment of missiles, etc. Second, a concerted effort to
undermine the popularity of the stronger, radical groups, such as the Tute
Bianca or White Overalls, through smear campaigns, accusations that they
cooperate with the police, etc. If necessary, we will plant actual bombs to
increase the climate of fear.
Recruitment and infiltration: We will concentrate on infiltrating the Black
Bloc and strategically placing provocateurs who will be in positions to
instigate attacks, violence, and destruction of private property which will
turn the population against the protestors. In addition, we will encourage
Fascist groups to run as segments of the Bloc that will then give us an excuse
to attack the main body of protestors.
Friday, 20 July. We arm the police and carabinieri with live ammunition rather
than rubber or plastic bullets. With luck, deaths will result. Our Bloc can
appear strategically near any group we wish to attack, giving us the excuse to
gas and beat the “nonviolent” demonstrators. Protestors should be severely
beaten and arrested protestors tortured to deter them from further
demonstrations. In addition, our Bloc will instigate the destruction of
property, particularly small shops, private cars, and will attack and beat
other demonstrators, perhaps even a nun or two, further discrediting the
anarchists. A high level of violence and destruction should lessen the numbers
expected for Saturday’s march.
Saturday, 21 July. Our strategy here is directed to undermine, divide, and
disperse the march. We instigate more property damage and police battles in
the morning near the assembly point of the march. One of our factions will
attack the Tute Bianca during the march. Shortly after noon, we begin a battle
just outside the convergence center, near the corner where the march turns
north, giving us the excuse to gas the convergence center. We attempt to drive
the battle into the march, splitting or disrupting it, and providing the
rationale to attack the march with tear gas and other dispersal agents.
Post-march. We continue the climate of fear with a midnight raid on the main
communications center and sleeping quarters of the protestors. Severe force is
justified by rumors of Black Bloc presence. We uncover “evidence” of
connections between the Genova Social Forum and the bloc, thereby discrediting
them. Beatings, arrests, and torture will discourage future involvement with
Phase Six: Sunday, 22
July and beyond: We continue harassment and random arrests of foreigners and
suspected protestors. We begin a campaign of accusations against the Genoa
Social Forum, connecting them with the Black Bloc, moving against their
employment, their credibility, and possibly taking legal action against them.
This will also force them to disavow the Black Bloc, further splitting the
This memo is
fiction, but I believe it’s essentially true. Like a mathematical proof, it
has a simple internal consistency that makes sense of the known facts. There
is more and more mounting evidence that the Black Bloc in Genoa was
significantly composed of organized fascist groups working in collaboration
with the police.
If it is true,
even partly true, what does it mean to us? It means that the response to the
events in Genoa will determine what level of force can be used against future
demonstrations, whether we will see smashed skulls and more deaths in Calgary,
and blowtorches in the armpits in the third world.
signs, however, that their strategy may backfire. On Monday, July 23 all over
Italy 250,000 people took to the streets. The pressure was on for the Minister
of the Interior to resign; Berlusconi’s government is threatened. There were
demonstrations at Italian embassies all over the world.
We need to keep
the pressure on, to make sure the issue doesn’t fade away. For if this level
of repression goes unchallenged, no one is safe, not the most legal NGO, not
the most reformist organization with the mildest demands. If we don’t act now,
when a political space remains open to us, we may lose the space to act at
all. Continue to organize and mobilize for the next one. Fear is their most
powerful weapon. The fact that they must resort to fascist violence shows that
we are a serious threat.
If we want to
continue to be a threat, we also need to look critically at our own movement,
to identify what we do that leaves us wide open to infiltration and
manipulation. We need both better preparation and better networks of support
for these actions. Z