“I’ve been working here four years,” a gravedigger who gave his name as Ali told IPS at the largest cemetery in
“Twenty-five percent of these were from violence, and another 70 percent were killed by the Mehdi Army (the militia of Shia cleric Muqtada Al-Sadr).” Only a few appeared to have died from natural causes.
“Most of the dead were never logged by anyone,” Ali said, “because we didn’t check death certificates, we just tried to get the bodies into the ground as quickly as possible.”
An Iraqi Army checkpoint was set up outside the vast cemetery a year ago.
“We opened this checkpoint because people were burying the dead and no information was being given to anyone,” a soldier, speaking on condition of anonymity because he was not authorised to speak to the media, told IPS.
“Most of this (lack of reporting the dead), we found, happened during 2006,” the soldier added. “Anyone could be buried here, and nobody would know about it.”
Not far, in the Al-Adhamiya area of
“Most of the bodies buried here are never reported in the media,” Abu Ayad Nasir Walid, 45, manager of the cemetery told IPS. He has been the manager here since the park was converted into a cemetery amidst the bloodletting from sectarian violence in early 2006.
“I have the name here of the first martyr buried,” Walid said, pointing to a tombstone. “Gaith Al-Samarai, buried on 21 May 2006, he was the sheikh of the Al-Hurria mosque.”
Latif produced the cemetery logbook. “As of this hour, exactly, there are 5,500 bodies in this place. I log their names in my book, but we’ve never had anyone come from the government to ask how many people are here. Nobody in the media nor the Ministry of Health seems to be interested.”
Such graveyards, and there are many, raise questions about the real death toll in
The last serious study, by a group of doctors in the
The study said about 655,000 Iraqis (2.5 percent of the population) had been killed as a direct result of the invasion and occupation. The research was carried out on the ground by doctors moving from house to house, questioning families, and examining death certificates.
Homes were surveyed in 47 separated clusters across
The worst of the violence followed the Feb. 22, 2006 bombing of the Al-Askari shrine in
“During that time we buried 30-40 bodies daily,” Sehel Abud Al-Latif, a gravedigger at the Al-Adhamiya cemetery told IPS. “Often we had to work through the night, otherwise the bodies would just remain outside.”
Some estimates of the death toll have been considerably lower than that of The Lancet. The group Iraq Body Count (IBC), which describes itself as an “ongoing human security project,” estimates the number to be 98,850 as of the time of this writing.
The group says on the methodology: “Deaths in the database are derived from a comprehensive survey of commercial media and NGO-based reports, along with official records that have been released into the public sphere.”
IBC adds that figures are included from “incident-based accounts to figures from hospitals, morgues and other documentary data-gathering agencies.”
The website adds, however, that “IBC’s main sources are information gathering and publishing agencies, principally the commercial news media who provide web access to their reports.” Also, the IBC only records violent deaths, and only those of civilians.
The unofficial cemeteries around