Public school teachers in Los Angeles are returning to classrooms today after approving an agreement to end a historic 6-day strike. The strike was the first in Los Angeles in three decades. It came after more than 20 months of strained negotiations between the union—United Teachers Los Angeles—and the school district. The strike effectively shut down Los Angeles Unified, the nation’s second largest school district. On Tuesday morning, union leaders and Los Angeles city officials announced that they had reached a deal on a new contract. After a vote, the union announced Tuesday night that the contract had been approved by a supermajority of UTLA members. Included in the agreement are pay increases for teachers, additional support staff in schools, smaller class sizes and the regulation of charter schools. For more, we speak with the union’s bargaining committee chair, Arlene Inouye, as well as labor journalist and author Sarah Jaffe.
AMY GOODMAN: We begin the show in Los Angeles, where public school teachers are returning to school today after approving an agreement to end a historic 6-day strike. The strike was the first in Los Angeles in three decades. It came after more than 20 months of strained negotiations between the union—the United Teachers Los Angeles—and the school district. The strike effectively shut down Los Angeles Unified, the nation’s second largest school district. On Tuesday morning, union leaders and Los Angeles city officials announced they had reached a deal on a new contract. This is Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti.
MAYOR ERIC GARCETTI: I’m proud to announce that, pending approval by the teachers of—they’re represented by UTLA—and education professionals and the Board of Education, that we have an agreement that will allow our teachers to go back to work on their campuses tomorrow.
AMY GOODMAN: After a vote, the union announced Tuesday night the contract had been approved by a supermajority of UTLA members. Included in the agreement are pay increases for teachers, additional support staff in schools, smaller class sizes and the regulation of charter schools. Alex Caputo-Pearl, president of United Teachers Los Angeles, praised the striking teachers.
ALEX CAPUTO–PEARL: We have seen, over the last week, something pretty amazing happen. We went on strike, in one of the largest strikes that the United States has seen in decades. And the creativity and innovation and passion and love and emotion of our members was out on the street, in the communities, in the parks, for everyone to see. And I’m so proud of our members—classroom teachers, counselors, nurses, librarians, psychologists, early educators, adult educators—who took it upon themselves, in record numbers on picket lines, to express what we’ve all known but has been a truth hard to tell sometimes, which is that public education desperately needs attention, from the city, from the country, from the state.
AMY GOODMAN: Los Angeles Unified School District Superintendent Austin Beutner also spoke Tuesday at the news conference, explaining four key areas where an agreement had been reached.
AUSTIN BEUTNER: The first was to provide a fair 6 percent increase to all who work in schools. The second was to reduce class sizes, provide more support to educators in schools, more nurses, counselors and librarians. The third was to invest every nickel we have in our classrooms, while maintaining the fiscal solvency of Los Angeles Unified. And the last, probably the most important, is to strengthen the voice of educators and provide more opportunities for collaboration for all who work in our schools.
AMY GOODMAN: Well, for more, we’re joined by two guests. Arlene Inouye is chair of the bargaining team for United Teachers Los Angeles, or UTLA. She’s also the UTLA secretary. And Sarah Jaffe is with us here in New York, reporting fellow at the Type Media Center, formerly The Nation Institute. She’s author of Necessary Trouble: Americans in Revolt.
We welcome you both to Democracy Now! Arlene Inouye, let’s begin with you. We see you in all of these images as the announcements were being made. Democracy Now! has just returned from Los Angeles. We went to the major rally right before the announcement, where firefighters had joined with the teachers in protesting. Talk about the agreement that was reached, the striking teachers voted for last night. What exactly did you achieve?
ARLENE INOUYE: Yes, thank you, Amy. This was a historic agreement and, actually, much—even gave us more than we had expected, although we had very, very strong demands, and we were clear that we had—these demands needed to be met. And they included, basically, investing in our students, a respect for educators and to stop the privatization of our schools.
So, specifically, we were able to lower class sizes by anywhere from up to seven, one to seven students in a class, depending on which kind of classroom you have, and to eliminate a provision that was in our contract that allowed the district to unilaterally increase class sizes. So, that’s out. And we were also able to get a nurse at every school five days a week, which was exactly what we asked for; more academic counselors, so that there’s a ratio of 500 to 1. We also asked for teacher librarians to be brought back into our middle and high schools, so that’s hiring of 41 additional teacher librarians. Mental health professionals—we were able to get funding for different sources so we can lower the ratio for psychiatric social workers, psychologists, pupil services attendance counselors. There were gains for a lot of our—the diversity of our unions, a lot of the different groups, such as substitutes, such as early educators, such as adult educators. We have bilingual education in there.
We have a provision to stop the—to allow for a charter cap to be introduced at the state level. We have a state law that allows unregulated charter schools to be, you know, started up anywhere, and it’s an unlimited number. So now we have a cap on that, and also, for the very first time, a co-location article in our contract, meaning that we’ve set—we put the educators involved in the process that allows charter schools to come onto our public school campuses and to take over the space that the district says is unoccupied. And this is a state law that’s been very difficult for L.A. Unified, because we have basically segregated campuses where we have charter schools on one side and our public school on the other hand. And sometimes the charter schools, very often, have lower class sizes. So, we’re able to compete with the charter schools by making our conditions better. We’re also able to put into the contract community schools, which is our alternative to charter schools. And that’s bringing the investments into the neighborhood school and allowing the parents, the educators and students to have a say in the curriculum, whether it’s music, art, dual language, ethnic studies, whatever it is that that community will be able to develop and be connected with parents.
So, this is our vision for public schools. And we are so excited that we’re able to move this vision forward and to address the unregulated charter school growth in L.A., which we’re ground zero for here. And we have over 270 unregulated charter schools. And we knew that this is about the survival of public education. It’s about the desperate resources we’ve needed in our classrooms. We’ve had classes, I think you’ve heard, you know, in the thirties in our elementary school, and forties and fifties and even sometimes sixties in our high school. We have kids sitting on window sills.
AMY GOODMAN: Sixty kids in a class?
ARLENE INOUYE: That’s correct. We do. We’ve documented, for example, the highest—you know, the hundred highest class sizes. We have secondary schools where they have a caseload of 500, 300 to 500 students on a caseload. That’s how many kids our educators see in a day.
AMY GOODMAN: We’re going to go to—
ARLENE INOUYE: So, these—
AMY GOODMAN: We’re going to go to break.
ARLENE INOUYE: Go ahead, Amy.
AMY GOODMAN: And then we’re going to come back to this discussion. Arlene Inouye, chair of the bargaining team for UTLA, United Teachers Los Angeles. Sarah Jaffe will also be joining us, who’s been writing about this strike. This is Democracy Now! When we come back, we’ll talk more about the message this is sending to others around the country about the privatization of education. Also, Denver teachers just voted to go on strike. They’ll be striking on Monday. Stay with us.
[break]
AMY GOODMAN: “People Have the Power” by Patti Smith. This is Democracy Now!, democracynow.org, The War and Peace Report. I’m Amy Goodman, in New York right now, just flew in on the red-eye from Los Angeles. When we came into Los Angeles yesterday morning, we went to a rally of hundreds of teachers and firefighters from Los Angeles, from New York, as well, unions that had come in solidarity to support the striking teachers. We spoke with a number of those teachers and supporters just before the agreement was reached between United Teachers Los Angeles and the school district. Again, this was the first teachers’ strike in Los Angeles in 30 years. I began by speaking with teacher Marianne O’Brien.
AMY GOODMAN: Can you tell us about the school we’re standing outside of? And you’re a teacher. What grade do you teach? And why are you here?
MARIANNE O’BRIEN: So, we’re at the Miguel Contreras Learning Complex. It’s made up of four schools. The school that we’re at is the Los Angeles School of Global Studies. And I’m a 10th grade English teacher.
AMY GOODMAN: And why are you out here?
MARIANNE O’BRIEN: We’re out here today for a number of reasons. I mean, we do want better resources for our school. We went a higher salary. We want smaller class size, less testing. But I think, ultimately, this fight is about the privatization of schools. We have a superintendent, Austin Beutner, who is right now pushing to privatize schools. And that’s a problem for us, because our students would be disproportionately hurt by that and not have access to a quality education, if all the funding for public school is pulled into charter schools.
AMY GOODMAN: Explain how that works.
MARIANNE O’BRIEN: It’s not a private school; it’s a charter school. So, a charter school works in that it has more autonomy, so it would pull funding from public schools to make their own school. And that’s a problem. Because they have more autonomy, they’re allowed to choose which students get to go to their schools, and they’re allowed to kick out students. They’re also allowed to fire teachers. So, it’s a problem because they get to choose which students go into their schools, so they’re not going to choose the students who have IEPs, who are English learners. And those are the students who go to our—
AMY GOODMAN: IEP?
MARIANNE O’BRIEN: That’s special ed, Individualized Education Plan.
AMY GOODMAN: And what’s your name? And where do you teach? What do you teach?
LILIT AZARIAN: My name is Lilit Azarian. I also teach at the School of Global Studies with Marianne here. I teach mainly ninth graders now in an ethnic studies class.
And I’m not just here for myself. I’m out here for my kids, because they can’t fight for what they deserve. And what they deserve are fully funded community schools. If the community school isn’t the best school available, then that’s a problem, because the community school should be the school where every single student can come and get a quality education. So, what we’ve been doing is funneling money from community schools to establish a completely disparate system that enables certain individuals, certain families access to a quality education, at the expense of others.
And my students deserve the best. My students deserve the most of my time, the most of my energy, but they also deserve a nurse on campus every single day of the week. They deserve a fully stacked library. They deserve psychiatric social workers, as so many have already mentioned. Our students come in with a lot of trauma. They need to—those needs need to be addressed before they can be able to learn in my classroom. So, I’m out here for them. This isn’t about us. This is not about our pay. That is by far the least important of our demands. This is about our kids and what they deserve.
AMY GOODMAN: This is the second largest school district in the country, and it’s 75 percent Latino?
LILIT AZARIAN: Yes. So, this is about fighting for, you know, communities of color, because those are the communities that are affected by this privatization that’s taken over. And unfortunately, it’s taken a strike to get attention to this really critical issue. I would much rather—all of us would much rather be in our classrooms with our kids right now. We’re out here because we feel like we have to, because this is the only way that we can make our voices heard, on behalf of our students.
AMY GOODMAN: Teachers at the Miguel Contreras Learning Complex, which houses four schools, right before the announcement came down that the teachers and the district had reached an agreement. The teachers voted on it last night, and more than 31,000 teachers will go back to school today.
Our guests are Arlene Inouye, chair of the bargaining team for UTLA and UTLA secretary—that’s United Teachers Los Angeles—and Sarah Jaffe of the Type Media Center, formerly The Nation Institute.
Sarah, you’ve been following this closely.
SARAH JAFFE: Yeah.
AMY GOODMAN: This deep concern about the privatization of public education and the resources, public resources—
SARAH JAFFE: Yeah.
AMY GOODMAN: —being funneled to private corporations. And particular concern in the raff I repeatedly heard yesterday from the teachers expressed against the superintendent, Austin Beutner—
SARAH JAFFE: Yeah.
AMY GOODMAN: —who didn’t come from an education background but from a hedge fund.
SARAH JAFFE: Yeah, he’s a Wall Street guy, and he certainly became a big hate object for the teachers that I spoke to. There were so many “Austin Beutner’s got to go” chants. And also from parents and students, I should say. They definitely have a lot to say about Austin Beutner. He came in, seen as somebody who came in with a plan, which was to privatize the district, break it up into 32 portfolio districts, which is something like what they did in Newark with Cory Booker. And—
AMY GOODMAN: When he was mayor.
SARAH JAFFE: When he was mayor, yes. And so, the teachers, the students and the parents were angry enough at Austin Beutner to actually go to his house on Thursday evening and have a rally outside of his house and say, you know, “We have questions about privatization. We have questions about the gentrification of our city. We want to live in an affordable place that has public schools that everybody can access.” And they see him as an obstacle in this.
And one of the teachers last night that I spoke with retweeted one of my tweets about the press conference saying, “He still has to go.” So, they are not satisfied. And actually, there’s an interesting story to follow up on this, which is that there’s going to be a special school board election coming up very soon.
AMY GOODMAN: Talk about the significance of that, what happened to the school board, how Superintendent Beutner was chosen.
SARAH JAFFE: Yeah, so the school board was elected in an election last year that had something like $14.7 million in outside funding spent on it by charter school advocates, big dollar hedge funds, things like that—the usual people that we see that roll into these places. So they got a majority of pro-charter school candidates on there. They put Beutner in.
And then one of the school board members—and Arlene, I’m sure, can talk much more about this—had to leave the board because of a scandal about campaign funding. So now there’s going to be a special election for his seat. The teachers have their candidate who’s going to be running. They have others that are going to be seen as more pro-charter school. And that’s going to be the next big fight, because, well, if the teachers want Beutner gone, that’s going to be the way to do it.
AMY GOODMAN: Arlene Inouye, can you talk about the message that’s being sent and your particular struggle around the school board and what you want to see happen, how you see this whole debate around charter schools shaping up now that the strike has ended?
ARLENE INOUYE: Yes, Amy. I feel like this strike has sent a powerful message throughout the country, and even the world, that public educators are standing up for our schools, our students and for ourselves. You know, we’re looking at decades of cuts and the demonization of public schools and the school teachers who work in them. This has been years in the making. And the use of standardized tests to, you know, rank students, rank schools, close schools, privatize schools, we know this is the model that’s coming. And LAUSD had, through—with Austin Beutner, had the “reimagine LAUSD,” that we were very concerned about.
So, what we have done through this strike, through this new contract, is to say no to the privatization of schools, where we’re ground zero, and to say yes to investing in our public schools, because we believe it’s a foundation of our democracy and a civic institution, that every student needs a quality education. We have a higher percentage of special needs in L.A. Unified, because the charter schools do not take the same proportion or choose to not accept the neediest kids in our city. And we are, you know, 90 percent students of color, 82 percent poverty and free lunch program. We want to now invest in the students who have been stripped of a quality education. We’ve had the highest class sizes in the nation. We are 48 out of 50.
So, we are ecstatic that this turns—is a turnaround, a real clear shift in the direction of our school district. And, again, we are a union that four years ago set out on this path. This just didn’t happen, you know, the last 21 months when we’ve been in negotiations. But four years ago, we set down a path to organize our schools, to bring in parents and communities and to have a social justice agenda, an educational justice agenda for all of our students. And so, that’s why it is so exciting to us, is because we see in fruition this all coming to pass.
And this is what other unions across the nation, other teachers’ unions, are also fighting for, the same issues. You know, in different degrees, we have the same issues of the privatization of our schools and of the funding. So, we are part of this movement—
AMY GOODMAN: I wanted to—
ARLENE INOUYE: —that began with Chicago—
AMY GOODMAN: I wanted to talk about the—
ARLENE INOUYE: —in 2012, and continues.
AMY GOODMAN: —the progressive Union Power caucus, Sarah, and the significance of it within the UTLA.
SARAH JAFFE: Yeah. So, like Arlene said, the movement that we have seen among teachers’ unions, really, we got a wind of it in Chicago, but there has been reform currents within the UTLA for at least a decade. Teachers told me about movements going back to the 2008 financial crisis, recession, the layoffs of a lot of teachers, the attempts to form a caucus really coming out of that, and, in 2014, becoming the Union Power caucus that took charge, that—with teachers like Arlene, with Alex Caputo-Pearl, that brought in things like an organizing department, a research department, a political department, that the union didn’t have before, and actually voted to raise their own dues in order to do those things. So, you know, in the post-Janus climate for public sector workers, we really should be looking at a union that, again, got teachers to vote to increase their own dues to invest in really becoming a fighting, organizing union.
And when we talk about this district, I was really struck by how geographically huge it is. Right? I live here in New York, which is the biggest school district in the country. But you could fit I don’t know how many New Yorks inside the 960 square miles of the L.A. Unified School District. So, when they got a 98 percent strike vote in this district, that takes three hours to drive across, they really had to build, from the bottom up, structures that got them in communication with every teacher in every school, in order to do this and then to pull off this strike, where pretty much every teacher went out.
AMY GOODMAN: So, talk about the significance of this strike and what’s now happening.
SARAH JAFFE: Yeah.
AMY GOODMAN: We see Denver teachers who just overwhelmingly voted to strike. I want to turn to what happened last night, Denver teachers voting to strike for the first time in 25 years, in a quarter of a century. The strike could begin as soon as Monday. This is Rob Gould, lead negotiator for the DCTA. That’s the Denver Classroom Teachers Association.
ROB GOULD: Tonight, Denver teachers overwhelmingly agreed to strike. Ninety-three percent voted to strike. They’re striking for better pay. They’re striking for our profession. And they’re striking for Denver students.
AMY GOODMAN: Arlene Inouye, what are some words of wisdom you have for your colleagues in Denver? This strike to begin, apparently, on Monday.
ARLENE INOUYE: Yes, and we’re excited for the educators in Denver that they’ve taken this step.
And I feel like what we’ve learned through the years is that when you communicate clearly what the message is and you reach out to parents and community, our collective power is what got us to win. We have a chapter leader in every single school. And we have teams now, organizing teams, at every school. And we have constant communication. I think, as you see, Amy, when you talk to anybody, any teacher or parent out there that were on the picket lines, they will tell you the same message, why we’re fighting. And it’s very clear to us.
And I think by being able to organize across the board and bring in the voices, the ordinary voices of our parents and our educators—and I, myself, by the way, am a speech and language specialist. I worked 18 years in L.A. Unified. And we have a diverse work—diverse membership, including speech and language, including health and human services, OT/PT, you know, psychiatric social workers, and so forth. And sometimes these little groups feel like their voices aren’t heard. But we were able to give—we were able to draw attention to all of the needs in our schools, all of the professionals, and also the students, of course, and what they need, and really lift this up and to see it as an issue of social justice in our schools.
We were also able to bring in some nonmandatory subjects of bargaining into our schools, which we call common good issues, like green space on campus, stopping the criminalization of youth through the wanding. We were able to bring in an immigrant defense fund. We’re making a statement of our values and of what’s critical for how our schools need to address the needs of our students.
AMY GOODMAN: What do you think that the district and Superintendent Beutner—what do you think they miscalculated when it came to the power of the strike? I mean, again, in Los Angeles, you went out for the first time in 30 years.
ARLENE INOUYE: Yes. And thank you for that question, Amy, because I do believe—I kept saying all along that Beutner has no idea of who he’s fighting with, because we have very, very strong emotions, very—a tenacity in our members and parents, as was reported earlier. They even went to his home to give—to let him know how they feel and how serious this matter is. I think when you come together with all of the voices, and including our students, I’ve got to say—students are coming out in record numbers on the picket line. And as was mentioned in the earlier interview with Alex, it’s a beautiful sight to see. I have never seen a strike like this, where you’re actually celebrating. It was like a love fest. And I think it’s because of the affirmation and the validation that our educators felt and the connection with our parents and communities.
AMY GOODMAN: It was hard to conduct our interviews—
ARLENE INOUYE: So, that’s a power.
AMY GOODMAN: It was hard to conduct our interviews yesterday, because as people were driving by, everyone was honking. The students were out with the teachers. You know, they weren’t saying, “Oh, this is great: This is a week off for us.” They were saying, “No, through the rain, through the cold, we are here, side by side, because we know our teachers are here for us.” Sarah, you used to live in Denver, and now you’re covering the L.A. strike. And talk about Oakland, as well—
SARAH JAFFE: Yeah.
AMY GOODMAN: —what’s about to happen there. And let’s just say, California and Colorado, these are two Democratic states.
SARAH JAFFE: Yeah, yeah.
AMY GOODMAN: Jared Polis, now the governor of Colorado.
ARLENE INOUYE: That’s right.
AMY GOODMAN: And, of course, you have Gavin Newsom.
SARAH JAFFE: Yeah.
AMY GOODMAN: And you have Eric Garcetti, the mayor of Los Angeles, who was the one who mediated these debates—the negotiations.
SARAH JAFFE: Yeah, and Colorado was still considered a red state when I lived there. I left in 2004. But what we’re seeing is the sort of return to the blue states of the teachers’ rebellion. Right? We saw last year was the sort of “Red for Ed” strike, although Colorado did have a day of action during all of that. But this all really began, you know, again, in Chicago. There was reform movements in places like Massachusetts and New York. And it’s been a real challenge to these Democrats, because, you know, again, California has been a blue state for as long as you and I can remember, and it is 43rd in per-student funding. That is on the level with some of these “Red for Ed” states. And that is the same problem they’re facing in Oakland.
AMY GOODMAN: It used to be one of the top in the country.
SARAH JAFFE: Right, it used to be one of the top in the country. And this is—Alex Caputo-Pearl will make the point—
AMY GOODMAN: Now it’s gone down to 43rd.
SARAH JAFFE: —that as the proportion of students of color in those schools went up, the number—the amount of, you know, per-student funding went down. And so, when you see these fights happening in these blue states—right?—again, Democrats have been in favor of charter schools. I mentioned Cory Booker earlier. We have, you know, had this experience here in New York. It’s been bipartisan policy to sort of beat up on teachers and argue that privatizing the schools will make them better.
And we’re finally really seeing really incredible pushback on that front, and it’s changing the way a lot of people talk about it. It was notable when the NAACP came out for a moratorium on charter schools recently, right? They had been in favor of charter schools. This is changing. And it’s changing because of teachers like Arlene. It’s changing because of the teachers in Chicago, the teachers in Massachusetts, and now the teachers in Colorado, and probably next in Oakland.
AMY GOODMAN: And Oakland?
SARAH JAFFE: Yeah. In Oakland, I spoke to teachers. I was there in December. And the complaints are very similar to what they are in Los Angeles, right? They’re overcrowded. They’re underfunded. Charter schools are cherry-picking the best students. And, you know, that’s—the charter schools, on one hand, they can push them out, but, on the other hand, you have to apply to get into charter schools. So, already you get the kids whose parents are more involved, who have time to do that, who are—as somebody pointed out to men, you know, undocumented students, their parents, especially under Trump, are really afraid to fill out any form and put any information down. So that means that those kids don’t get into charters, because they’re not applying to get into those charters.
AMY GOODMAN: And one of the things teachers kept repeating to me over and over yesterday was, in charter schools, the teachers can be fired, and the students can be fired.
SARAH JAFFE: Mm-hmm, yeah. We should mention that the Accelerated Schools, a charter school in Los Angeles, went out on strike with this UTLA strike, starting last Tuesday. And yeah, they were telling me 40 percent turnover at that school among teachers. I mean, how do you do anything when you don’t know if you’re going to have your job next year?
AMY GOODMAN: Well, we’re going to continue to cover this wave of strikes. Again, Oakland, it looks like they’re about to vote. And Denver teachers overwhelmingly voted to strike last night. The Los Angeles teachers, over 31,000, are back in their classrooms today and at their offices, as they have just claimed victory in the 6-day historic strike, first one in 30 years. I want to thank Arlene Inouye, chair of the bargaining team for UTLA and UTLA secretary, and Sarah Jaffe of the Type Media Center, formerly known as The Nation Institute.
Please Help ZNet and Z Magazine
Due to problems with our programming that we have only now finally been able to fix, it has been over a year since our last fund raising. As a result, we need your help more than ever to continue to bring the alternative information you have been looking for for 30 years.
Z offers the most useful societal news we can, but in judging what is useful, unlike many other sources we emphasize vision, strategy, and activist relevance. When we address Trump, for example, it is to find ways beyond Trump, not to merely repeat, over and over, how terrible he is. And the same is true for our addressing global warming, poverty, inequality, racism, sexism, and war making. Our priority is always that what we provide has potential for aiding determining what to do, and how best to do it.
In fixing our programming problems, we have updated our system to make becoming a sustainer and giving donations easier. It has been a long process but we are hopeful it will make it more convenient for everyone to help us grow. If you have any trouble, please let us know right away. We need input on any problems to make sure the system can continue to be easy to use for everyone.
The best way to help, however, is to become a monthly or annual sustainer. Sustainers can comment, post blogs, and receive a nightly commentary by direct email.
You can also or alternatively make a one-time donation or get a print subscription to Z Magazine.
Subscribe to Z Magazine here.
Any aid will help greatly. And please email any suggestions for improvements, comments, or problems right away.
ZNetwork is funded solely through the generosity of its readers.
Donate